Which Is Better: SilverSingles.com or OurTime? The Ultimate 2025 Guide for Over-50 Dating

Choosing the right dating platform sets the tone for your journey toward meaningful companionship. If you’re 50 or older and trying to decide between SilverSingles.com and OurTime, you’re not alone. Both sites cater specifically to seniors but take different approaches in features, pricing, user base, and community atmosphere.

Overview: SilverSingles vs. OurTime — Key Differences at a Glance

• Target Audience: Both sites focus on singles aged 50 and above, but technically allow users 18 and older.

• Matching Approach: SilverSingles uses a personality-based compatibility system, while OurTime relies more on location and user-driven search.

• Pricing Models: SilverSingles offers an all-inclusive subscription with no extra fees, whereas OurTime’s base prices seem low but add-ons often increase the total cost.

• User Base Size: OurTime has a significantly larger user pool; SilverSingles has a smaller but more curated and compatibility-focused community.

• User Experience: SilverSingles emphasizes quality over quantity in matches; OurTime allows more browsing and flexibility.

1. Matching System: Compatibility vs. Search Flexibility

SilverSingles: Compatibility-Focused

• Requires a detailed personality test during sign-up, based on the Five Factor Model.

• Delivers 3–7 curated daily matches tailored to your values, lifestyle, and preferences.

• Focuses on fostering long-term, serious relationships.

• Users experience less time “shopping” for matches thanks to algorithmic filtering.

OurTime: Search & Location-Based

• No mandatory personality quiz; profiles are matched mainly by demographic filters like age, location, and interests.

• Users can browse actively, filtering matches and engaging in traditional online dating behaviors like swiping or favoriting.

• Offers “Our Picks” and “MatchMe” features for guided but user-controlled matching.

• Appeals to those who want more control and a larger pool to explore.

2. User Base and Activity

• OurTime boasts around 8.9 million monthly visitors, making for a vibrant, bustling community and a broad pool of potential matches. This scale can be especially beneficial if you live in less densely populated areas.

• SilverSingles has about 800,000 monthly visitors, a smaller community but one focused primarily on users serious about meaningful relationships.

3. Pricing Comparison: All-Inclusive vs. Add-On Model

Add-Ons on OurTime:

• Private Mode ($9.99/mo) to hide your profile from new views.

• Reply for Free ($6.99/mo) letting free members message you.

• Super Likes, ConnectMe phone feature, and more upsells increase overall cost.

SilverSingles offers one transparent subscription covering all features with no surprise addons.

4. Features & User Experience

SilverSingles Advantages:

• Deeper compatibility thanks to psychology-based matchmaking.

• All-in-one paid plan simplifies the experience.

• Strong customer support, including telephone assistance.

• Fewer spam profiles due to rigorous paid gating and personality test barrier.

OurTime Strengths:

• Large user base increases chances of local matches.

• Flexible browsing and searching capabilities.

• Built-in video chat and other communication options.

• More casual and activity-friendly community.

Drawbacks:

• SilverSingles can feel limited in browsing scope and user quantity.

• OurTime’s many add-ons cause confusion and potential unexpected expenses.

• Some reviewers find OurTime’s customer support lacking and report more fake accounts.

5. Relationship Goals & Community Vibe

• SilverSingles prioritizes users seeking serious, long-term connections, often attracting those who want stable companionship and meaningful conversations.

• OurTime has a wider range of relationship intentions, including friendship and casual dating alongside serious relationships, due to its bigger and more diverse membership.

6. User Reviews & Reputation

• SilverSingles users praise the quality of matches and robust support but note the site is pricier and membership smaller.

• OurTime receives commendation for its size and interactivity but faces criticism for upsell practices and inconsistent customer service.

• Multiple reviews indicate that both sites have some fake profiles, but SilverSingles’ paid model and compatibility tests reduce their prevalence.

Read More: Can You Permanently Delete DateMyAge.com? The Complete 2025 Guide to Account Deletion, Data Privacy, and Total Profile Removal

Final Verdict: Which is Best for You?

• Choose SilverSingles.com if:

  • You want compatibility-driven matches with psychological depth.

  • You prefer an all-inclusive subscription without surprise fees.

  • You value strong customer support and a focused, serious community.

  • You like receiving fewer, higher-quality match suggestions daily.

• Choose OurTime if:

  • You want access to a larger dating pool with more local options.

  • You prefer to browse and search actively with greater control.

  • You want the flexibility of casual dating alongside potential romance.

  • You’re comfortable navigating and paying for add-ons for extra features.